Cottage Cheese Fudge – Easy, Irresistible Treat (5g Protein)

Cottage cheese fudge doesn’t sound real until you taste it. But here it is: chocolatey, creamy, packed with protein, and made with just a few fridge staples. Whether you’re cutting sugar, watching macros, or just want a snack that feels like dessert without tanking your energy, this recipe delivers. Below, I’ll show you how to turn blended curds into rich fudge—no baking, no tricks, just real food that works cold.

Table of Contents

What Makes Cottage Cheese Fudge Work

If you’ve been burned by chalky protein snacks or gritty low-sugar desserts, cottage cheese fudge is about to change your mind. It blends smooth, sets firm, and hits that chocolate craving without the crash. Unlike traditional fudge, which is loaded with butter and sugar, this version is built around protein-rich cottage cheese—and yes, it actually tastes good.

The Texture Surprise

When whipped in a blender, cottage cheese turns unexpectedly creamy—think Greek yogurt meets whipped ricotta. That becomes the foundation. Then you bring in melted chocolate or unsweetened cocoa to build a dense, chocolate base. No stovetop stirring, no candy thermometers—just a clean blend and freeze method.

You’ll find most versions of cottage cheese fudge keep it under 6 ingredients:

• Blended cottage cheese
• Dark chocolate or cocoa powder
• Maple syrup, honey, or monk fruit
• A splash of vanilla
• Maybe a shake of salt or added protein

You don’t need stabilizers or thickeners—just simple ingredients and a blender. Once chilled, the texture is surprisingly firm and creamy, with clean edges and a thick bite. It won’t crumble like protein bars or melt like classic fudge, but it gives you that rich square you can actually portion.

Why Everyone’s Talking About It

This recipe hit social media hard for a reason. It looks like a cheat snack, but it’s packed with protein and freezer-stable for weeks. No baking. No sugar rush. Just something you can cut up and toss in a prep container for after-lunch cravings.

It’s also versatile. You can swirl in almond butter, adjust the chocolate-to-cheese ratio, or even sneak in greens (really). We’ve played with cottage cheese in savory dishes like this carrot ribbon salad pairing and sweet potato bowls, but this sweet use? It’s the sleeper hit.

Ingredients + Prep Breakdown

This version of cottage cheese fudge keeps it tight and functional—no weird gums or protein powders unless you want them. All you need is a blender, a freezer, and five basic ingredients you probably already have.

Core Ingredients

This makes about 16 small squares:

• 1 cup cottage cheese (full-fat or low-fat)
• 1/2 cup dark chocolate chips or bar
• 1 to 2 tablespoons natural sweetener (maple syrup, honey, stevia, or monk fruit)
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• Pinch of salt to balance the sweetness

Optional upgrades:

• A scoop of your go-to protein powder
• A spoonful of peanut butter or tahini
• Cacao nibs or chopped walnuts pressed into the top

The ingredients list keeps it in the same universe as our cottage cheese dry curd recipes, but this one plays for the sweet team.

How to Make It

Step 1: Blend It Smooth
Start by melting the chocolate using a double boiler or short bursts in the microwave. Once melted, toss it into your blender with the cottage cheese, sweetener, vanilla, and salt. Run until smooth—no lumps, no grit.

Step 2: Set It Up
Scrape the fudge batter into a loaf pan or container lined with parchment paper. Spread evenly with a spatula or spoon.

Step 3: Freeze to Firm
Transfer the container to your freezer and give it at least 2 hours. You’re aiming for a firm set that holds shape but still cuts clean.

Step 4: Slice & Stash
Once firm, cut into even squares and transfer to a lidded container. You can refrigerate for daily snacking (lasts up to 5 days) or keep them frozen long-term and just thaw before serving.

If you’re also prepping something savory—like our high protein taco bowl—this fudge makes a killer contrast when packed as a sweet add-on.

Print

Serving Ideas + Add-Ons

Once you’ve frozen and sliced your cottage cheese fudge, it opens up way more than just a snack-on-the-go. This stuff is surprisingly adaptable. Whether you’re keeping it simple or dressing it up for guests, there are easy ways to serve it that make it feel like more than a protein hack.

How to Plate or Pack It

Cottage cheese fudge works great in small bites, squares, or even scooped like truffles. Here are a few ways I use it in meal prep and quick snacks:

• Next to fresh fruit: Serve with banana slices, berries, or pomegranate for sweet-tart contrast
• Tucked into snack boxes: Include it with nuts and veggie sticks for a full protein break
• With plain yogurt or skyr: Drop a chunk into a high-protein bowl to balance flavor and texture
• Post-lunch treat: Add a square alongside something savory like our carrot ribbon salad for a clean finish

Since cottage cheese fudge firms up but doesn’t turn icy, it’s also travel-safe for a few hours. Toss a slice into a prep tray with your sweet potato protein bowl and you’ve got a solid sweet finish with no sugar crash.

Flavor Combos Worth Trying

Once you’ve got the base recipe down, cottage cheese fudge can be modified endlessly. Try:

• Mocha version: Mix in a little brewed espresso and cinnamon
• Nutty chocolate: Swirl in peanut butter or almond butter before freezing
• Spiced fudge: Add cayenne, chili powder, or black pepper for heat
• No sweetener: Skip syrup entirely and use dark chocolate only for a richer, less sweet take

You can even coat your fudge in crushed pistachios or hemp seeds to add texture without needing to bake or blend again. Cottage cheese fudge has enough body to hold toppings, which makes it more versatile than protein bars or mousse cups.

Cottage Cheese Fudge Questions, Answered

Conclusion: Cottage Cheese Fudge Is Worth Keeping in Your Freezer

Whether you’re trying to snack smarter or just want a dessert that doesn’t knock you out at 3 PM, cottage cheese fudge is the kind of recipe that makes real sense. It’s fast to blend, simple to store, and easy to tweak depending on what you have on hand.

You’re not melting butter or messing with sugar thermometers. You’re grabbing a few pantry basics, blending them up, freezing for a couple hours, and slicing off a piece whenever you need something solid, creamy, and chocolate-forward. It’s one of the most practical recipes to come out of the protein-forward trend—and unlike a lot of those, it actually holds up in a real meal prep week.

Need more sweet ideas that work on a weekday? Check out what Gina’s doing over at Skinnytaste. Or browse more prep-friendly desserts and snacks on Pinterest.